"I threw up from eating too much candy and the mask won't come off"!!

40 Great But Forgotten Horror Movies Part 3

Welcome to Part 3 of my list of the 40 great but forgotten horror movies.

I’m covering the most obscureunderrated, and unfairly ignored scary films worth checking out over Halloween. Be sure to read PART ONE and PART TWO if you haven’t already, to see earlier entries.

If you’d like to own any of these under-the-radar treasures,  I have  Amazon links under each entry


If I were to tell you William Shatner starred in a horror movie filmed entirely in Esperanto (the constructed ‘universal’ language which never took off), you’d think it was a turd right? Well, it’s actually  an atmospheric occult thriller, and the odd language gives it the air of an artsy foreign film (rumors of a curse on the cast and crew remain).

<img src="William Shatner in The Incubus .jpg" alt="The Incubus, underrated forgotten horror movie, esperanto" />

“It’s not that bad, I promise”…


18. “Eyes Without A Face”-(1960)

This creepy French film begins with a woman’s body dumped in a river. The corpse’s face was used by a deranged doctor, in a failed skin graft operation to repair his disfigured daughter’s face . They later lure another victim to the home and repeat the bizarre and cruel procedures. But things do not go as planned…This film was particularly gruesome for its time, and it still has an unsettling edge. And yes, that’s where Billy Idol got the song title from…



Available On Netflix Streaming. Currently Netflix offers a free, month-long trial of their service. Click Here to get started today

Rampage‘ is  based on serial killer Richard Chase, who felt compelled to drink the blood and innards of his victims. What makes the murderer so disturbing is his sunny, innocent demeanor. This adds conflict to the courtroom scene of the film, which debate the death penalty.  ‘Rampage’ is yet another underrated movie from talented director William Friedkin.


16. ‘Near Dark’-(1987)

Kathryn Bigelow (‘The Hurt Locker’) directed this visually stylish horror-western, about nomadic vampires who feed off victims in small rural towns. But they’re in jeopardy due to their new member Caleb, who has been turned against his will and wants to escape. ‘Aliens‘ actors Bill Paxton and Lance Henriksen steal the show and make the shaky plot forgivable.


15. ‘Attack The Block’-(2011)

Despite strong buzz, this movie was a box office dud. It’s a clever sci-fi horror film that takes place in London’s inner city, where a street gang are under siege from an alien invasion. It balances scares with humor and visual panache (the monster design is very cool). If you’re a fan of films like ‘Shaun of The Dead‘, this is a must see (FYI, actor Nick Frost has a supporting role).


14. ‘Jacob’s Ladder’-(1990)

This film stars Tim Robbin’s as Jacob, a Vietnam vet plagued with nightmares and hallucinations involving demonic creatures and a filthy hospital where he undergoes cruel experiments. An Army buddy claims they’re suffering side effects from ‘The Ladder‘, a drug used on them in the war, which was designed to heighten aggression.

This film is a constant guessing game on whether Jacob is insane, dreaming, or figuring out a government conspiracy. I feel the twist ending is predictable, but the creepy imagery and excellent performances make it worth viewing. (And the ‘head shake‘ sequences has been copied in tons of music videos and other horror films). Check out the original trailer:


13.’Duel’-(1971)/’Road Games’-(1981)

Duel‘ is Steven Spielberg’s directorial début. A cat and mouse tale about a motorist being relentlessly pursued by a sinister trucker , it’s well scripted (by ‘I Am Legend’s’ Richard Matheson’) and shows Spielberg’s early grasp on suspense and pacing.

Road Games‘, directed by Richard Franklin concerns a truck driver who keeps noticing a green van at various points during his route. When he hears there’s a serial killer in the area, he suspects the driver. The film veers into the Hitchcockian ‘wrongly accused man’ plot device as he finds himself blamed for the murders while trying to find the real killer.


12. ‘Psycho II’-(1983)

Speaking of Hitchcock, and Richard Franklin, he directed the sequel to Hitchcock’s classic. But how could he top the original? He doesn’t, but it’s still a fun thriller, with Anthony Hopkin’s returning as Norman Bates.  Bates has been released from the sanitarium. But Lila Lewis, the sister of victim Marian Crane is incensed. Bates returns to his home and hotel, which is under new management.

Between Marian’s scheme to get Norman recommitted, and Bates questioning his sanity when new murders occur at the Hotel, it’s a satisfying sequel with a great twist.


11. ‘Halloween III: The Season Of The Witch’-(1982)

Had this film not been called ‘Halloween III‘, I’m convinced it would be appreciated for its B-movie charms. But fans felt short-changed without Michael Myers, and it bombed.

But what’s not to love about a sinister toy maker who makes evil Halloween masks that will kill the wearer on Halloween night? And the only man who can stop it from happening, is Dr Dan Challis and the odds are against him. Humanoid robots, all sorts of creepy crawlies, and a nice John Carpenter score add up to a flick that’s undeserved of its hated reputation. But the music to the commercial triggering the carnage will drive you crazy!


“I threw up from eating too much candy and the mask won’t come off”!!

*I also think ‘Halloween II’ is a solid sequel, even if it can’t match the original, and feel Rob Zombie’s ‘Halloween’ , while an uneven film, still has some terrifying moments, and was unfairly critically thrashed.

So that wraps up Part 3! Now go read the recently finished TOP 10.  Be sure to check out all my other Halloween related goodness, including my review of the new horror anthology V/H/S , the Best Halloween Party Playlist, and the scariest  film scenes of all time.

About SLIS

Middle Aged Gen-Exer obsessed with Alternative rock, metal, cult movies, comic books and cable TV.

Follow Us

Follow Smells Like Infinite Sadness

, , , , , , , ,

11 Responses to 40 Great But Forgotten Horror Movies Part 3

  1. Jack Sommersby October 26, 2012 at 6:11 pm #

    Before it turns way too violent for its own good in the last third, “Psycho 2” is superb stuff. I like it better than the director’s “Road Games,” which just didn’t play as well as it did when I was younger.

    “Halloween 3” is still my favorite sequel of the series, and I’d rather have an enjoyable sequel w/o Myers than a crappy one with him! One of my favorite opening-credits music scores. I’m with you on “Jacob” — unsatisfying ending but excellent until then.

    “Rampage” was one of 1992’s best films, and I’ll definitely put “Eyes Without a Face” on my must-see list.

    • SLIS October 26, 2012 at 11:08 pm #

      It’s too bad they kept going with ‘Psycho’ sequels, because 3 was so bad. Remember how sleazy Jeff Fahey was in that? “Halloween 3″ is a fun flick. Do you remember when we used to champion part 4? Haven’t seen it ages so wonder how it holds up? ‘Resurrection” was by far the worst!

  2. Jack Sommersby October 27, 2012 at 10:09 am #

    No, *you* championed “Halloween 4.” I haven’t liked any of the sequels aside from part 3. And parts of “Psycho 3” are pretty good — the dark-comedy bits, especially. And, yeah, Fahey definitely looked like he needed a serious shower! He would’ve been perfectly in his element in “Bloodsucking Freaks”!

    • SLIS October 27, 2012 at 4:15 pm #

      Speaking of Fahey; remember the horrible “Body Parts”? And did you see “Machete”? That was a fun flick.

  3. Jack Sommersby October 28, 2012 at 7:04 am #

    I actually like “Body Parts,” which was written and directed by Eric Red, whose 1996 werewolf tale “Bad Moon” I also liked. And, of course, we both liked his screenplay for “The Hitcher.” And haven’t seen “Machete.”

    • SLIS October 28, 2012 at 4:18 pm #

      Red wrote “Near Dark” too didn’t he? And “Blue Steel”. I was going to put “Hitcher” on this list, but given it was remade I guess it’s had it’s due? Had the same dilemma with “The Fog”.

      You need to watch “Machete”. If you like Rodriguez’s stuff, it ranks among the best. Over the top B movie mayhem.


  1. Christmas Gifts Best DVD and Blu-Ray Sets of 2012, Great Movies and TV | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - November 24, 2012

    […] the satisfying sequel to John Carpenter’s original (the best horror movie ever), or the underrated part III,  these Shout! Factory special editions have great HD transfers and bonus material.17. They […]

  2. 5 Ways Richard Matheson Changed Science Fiction, author's influence | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - June 27, 2013

    […] early 70′s. This was the director’s first full length film. It remains an effective (if underrated) early example of Spielberg’s ability to wrangle tension and excitement from very rudimentary […]

  3. Top 20 Best Movie Sequels Of All Time, best film sequels ever made | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - July 15, 2013

    […] work is a blasphemer (yeah, I’m looking at you Gus Van Sant). So it’s a miracle that Richard Franklin’s follow-up to Hitchcock’s classic works so well. Credit a lively performance from Anthony Perkins, and […]

  4. 60 Most Badass Antiheroes Part 1, Best Anti-heroes In Film, TV, Comics | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - August 7, 2013

    […] is the leader of a group of young thugs, but redeems his mugging ways by helping to stop an alien rampage in inner city London, becoming a local legend in the […]

  5. 40 Great But Forgotten Horror Movies Part 2, underrated horror films | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - August 7, 2013

    […] So that concludes 40 Great But Forgotten Horror Movies Part 2. Now check out PART 3. […]

Leave a Reply