Album Review: Swans ‘The Seer’

30 years in, Swans make their masterpiece with ‘The Seer’. 

‘The Seer’ (Young God Records)

Rare is the band that’s still at their creative peak 30 years into their career. But Swans new album ‘The Seer’ is their best work to date. Founding member Michael Gira and co. seem brimming with purpose and demonic intensity.

It’s a daunting listen. A double album, featuring several tracks over 20 minutes long, it takes time to absorb. 2 weeks into it, and I’m still scrambling for the right words.

So let’s start at the top with Disc 1:

Lunacy‘ is one hell of an opener. It begins with an ethereal Middle Eastern wail, followed by eerie harmonized vocals (featuring Mimi Parker and Alan Sparhawk from Low). The repeated choral refrain of “Lunacy” is chilling and will make you question that your own sanity is slipping. Once the chanting climaxes, it lulls into a lament; “Your childhood is over“. But this album is just getting started.

Mother Of The World” has a death grip on your ears from its first clanging industrial riff. It’s repeated motif will test your patience, but it settles into a nice bluesy vibe towards the closing.

This album is like Texas weather. If you don’t like what you hear, wait a few minutes. Often times a single track sounds like multiple songs. This constantly morphing, labyrinthine approach is dizzying and disorienting.

The title track is impossible to classify. It’s over 30 minutes long and vacillates between hypnotic transcendence, nihilistic rage and abstract terror.

It’s followed by ‘The Seer Returns‘ . A slowly escalating track which also feels Arabic in tone. Gira’s lyrics are suitably abstract; “My light pours into your mouth/Your light pours into my mouth“. His vocals are alternately soothing and sinister (His old flame Jarboe adds her trademark wailing backing vocals)

 “93 Avenue Blues” is straight out of a horror score. It sounds like a gang of haunted apparitions engaging in S&M. Terrifying.

DISC 2 is still dark, but it does offer occasional uplift.

Song For A Warrior” features a great guest vocal from Yeah Yeah Yeah’s vocalist Karen O. The lilting country ballad sounds more akin to Mazzy Star than the Swans, soothing and restorative.

Avatar” is next, and it’s my favorite. Atmospheric and ethereal it has a powerful dark beauty. Thor Harris’s orchestral bells sound almost like an homage to Mike Oldfield’s ‘The Exorcist‘ theme. Indeed, much of what makes ‘The Seer’ so richly compelling is the addition of non-‘rock’ instrumentation. Orchestral instruments used here work at odd, unsettling angles, not the typical window dressing you find when most rock bands add a string section for a power ballad. When Gira’s vocals appear late in the song, it has a magnetic, Gothic drone.

A Piece Of The Sky” is another standout and sounds akin to the post-rock of Mogwai. Piano driven and hypnotic, it’s a beautiful piece of work. But it later veers into atypical territory with a playful melody and Gira’s laconic baritone crooning which is reminiscent of Johnny Cash.  He waxes poetic, a mix of whimsy and urban decay; “In the wind of our love, in methane and love/in petroleum plumes there’s a floating slice of moon/ in your tooth and your claws and your unforgiving jaws, are you there?

But lest one think Swans are mellowing out, the album closes with ‘Apostate‘, one bombastic, violent piece of noise rock that has Gira at his most manic with a profane delivery that sounds like a man with Tourette’s speaking in tongues.

Awhile back I put  Swans ‘The Great Annihilator‘  on my list of darkest albums. But it has nothing on ‘The Seer‘.

This album throws down the gauntlet. It’s a middle finger to the internet age of instant gratification, where music competes against a million other distractions, not allowing it to be the fully immersive experience its meant to be.

You can’t listen to ‘The Seer‘ in snippets. This is musical homework, an investment of your time. It’s a challenge, but a rewarding one. Live with it. Drive to it. Write to it. But don’t try to sleep to it, or you’ll have some epic nightmares.

*Here’s a great interview with Gira from The Quietus where he discusses the new album.

*You can buy or preview ‘The Seer‘ from iTunes below or click on the album image if you prefer to get the 2 CD set from Amazon.

[amazon_image id=”B008K7WCJM” link=”true” target=”_blank” size=”medium” ]Seer[/amazon_image]

**UPDATE: The Seer is our Best Album Of 2012. Check out the full list.


About SLIS

Middle Aged Gen-Exer obsessed with Alternative rock, metal, cult movies, comic books and cable TV.

Follow Us

Follow Smells Like Infinite Sadness

, , , , , ,

6 Responses to Album Review: Swans ‘The Seer’

  1. jo October 8, 2012 at 5:59 am #

    Great review. The Seer is one of my top ten for this year without a doubt

    “You can’t listen to ‘The Seer‘ in snippets. This is musical homework, an investment of your time. It’s a challenge, but a rewarding one. Live with it. Drive to it. Write to it.” How right you are, I like a challenge and this is anything but instant and disposable. I love discovering another layer each time I hear it. I hope to catch them in London in November if work doesn’t get in the way!

  2. SLIS October 8, 2012 at 9:53 am #


    Thanks for the kind words!
    Unfortunately I happened to be out of town when they played in my area :-(. Fingers crossed they’ll come back again at some point.

    And I agree on the layers. There’s just so much going on it takes a long time to absorb, and even after I did this review I find myself discovering new elements with repeat listens.


  1. Top 10 Best Albums Of 2012, best rock albums of 2012, Swans The Seer | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - December 13, 2012

    […] Uneasy listening in the best sense of the word. 30 Years into their career Michael Gira’s noise-rock outfit release their most ambitious and daunting project, a double album full of atonal hell and dark majestic beauty. (Click here for the full review). […]

  2. Top 40 Darkest Rock Albums Part 3, Doors,Black Sabbath, Marilyn Manson | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - May 25, 2013

    […] recently reviewed their new album ‘The Seer’. It earns an honorary 41st ranking! Insanely good and […]

  3. Album Review: Sigur Ros 'Kveikur', Sigur Ros branch out with Kveikur. | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - June 15, 2013

    […] stately Hrafntinna has an eerie chill reminiscent of Swans 2012 release The Seer, showcasing Jón "Jónsi" Þór Birgisson's vocals and augmented by dour […]

  4. The Best Halloween Party Music Playlist, best Halloween Song Mix | Smells Like Infinite Sadness - July 20, 2013

    […] The Suicide song “Frankie Teardrop” is a creepy song about murder/suicide, and “Hamburger Lady” by Throbbing Gristle is a sonically disturbing tale about a burn victim. They are super intense, and only for the musically adventurous. Same with ‘Lunacy‘ by Swans (check out my review of their latest album). […]

Leave a Reply